Pied Piper presented by Rosie.
Present: Denise Julie Maggie Mariannick Pat Peggy Murielle Rosie Wendy
Rosie began by giving some background on Nevil Shute. First she asked whether anyone had heard of him. Not many had before we picked him for this month’s book. Rosie said that he was well known in the UK, where many people read his books as young adults. In fact, A town called Alice figures on a list of 100 best books in the world. (We wondered who made the list, as there are many “best of” lists available.) The group’s attitude toward the book was very positive.
Born UK 1899 and died in1960, Shute lived his last 10 years in Australia. He had a stammer so was rejected from the Flying Corps but then enlisted in 1918. Had a distinguished career as an aeronautical engineer, was also a pilot. He had to conceal his career as a writer from his employers at Vickers! He began writing in 1926, He has been called “a born narrator”. His plot lines are considered to be clear, and understated, and to progress simply and logically, as we might expect of an engineer! He was also interested in the boundary between Science and beliefs, eg. Buddhist astrology.
His stories feature decent people behaving in quiet, heroic ways. He writes predominantly about the lives of people caught up in the Second World War. His characters are ordinary people who, while trapped in a time when it felt like the world was ending and unspeakable horrors were happening, show great kindness and a breadth of human compassion. Pied Piper was his 8th book. By this point he had the experience, the craft and the confidence to tell the story of Howard’s journey perfectly.
Rosie asked the group how we think a 1942 reader may have viewed a book like this compared to those of us who are reading it today with the benefit of hindsight and a knowledge of history. It was actually written during the war itself. At the time of writing, the author had no idea what would happen next or how the war would eventually end. Would you have wanted to read about war while it was still going on? We agreed that it’s a story that would boost people’s morale, since it shows the heroism of an unwilling and unprepared protagonist. It was immediately made into a film. The old man shows kindness and courage and succeeds in getting the children to safety. Katharine felt that he was able to give them the protection that he had been unable to give to his deceased son, John.
We discussed our conception of what 1942 was like. Rosie said that it was a difficult and dangerous time. There were many Allied defeats, including Germany driving deep into Soviet territory, Rommel pushing hard into Egypt, Japan conquering vast territories across Asia and the W Pacific, Darwin was bombed. It saw the greatest UK defeat ever, the Fall of Singapore, in which 80 thousand troops surrendered to Japan. By 1942 some people knew about the Holocaust. BUT the year ended with major turning points: the Battle of Midway in which the USA decisively defeated the Japanese fleet, sinking 4 aircraft carriers and halting Japanese expansion in the Pacific (June) ; the Allied forces defeated the Axis
forces in Egypt and secured N . Africa, opening up another front; the Red Army set up the historic victory of Stalingrad that would break the German army on the Eastern Front.
Rosie asked us what we thought makes Pied Piper different from other war novels. We noted that it’s a war novel without soldiers. And children are its focus. Normally we would expect to read about heroic deeds on the battlefield. Shute’s protagonist is very ordinary – not a soldier or a spy or a romantic young lover, but a quiet,
unassuming old man who becomes a hero unintentionally through a mixture of circumstance and his own basic decency and humanity. Pied Piper is a poignant tale of love and loss and the loneliness of old age. It displays Shute's prose at its sparest and most effective. It’s a classic story with that draws you right into the perils of WW2 in France.
Rosie asked whether we thought the the story line works. It’s a fable, as the title suggests. The reference to the older tale is ironic. Whereas the Pied Piper of Hamlin leads the children to oblivion, John Howard leads them to safety. And while the figure in the folk tale takes the children in order to get revenge, Howard doesn’t want to take the children. There’s a reference to the Piper in that Howard knows how to make whistles and he amuses the children by making them. Shute’s novel also uses the classic story line of a journey—like the Odyssey or Pilgrim’s Progress —with different adventures and obstacles to overcome. He keeps up our interest by adding different children to the troupe. Much of the plot hinges on frailties of age and youth. Howard is refused entry into the service in both wars. He’s making a contribution by taking the children to safety. Some of the pleasure in the book comes from the depiction of the children, which seems very true to life. Ronnie is fascinated by the machines of war, especially the planes and tanks. His little sister tries to copy what he does and always asks for what he wants too.
Someone asked about the fact that the kids had no papers. But there was no national identity card and there is none now in England. You did have to have papers in the war though. Denise had a question about Nicole. How soon did we realise she was Howard’s son’s girlfriend? For some of us it was pretty soon. Lots of hints were dropped as the narrative progressed, so we probably realised before Howard did.
Pat was interested in Howard's attitude to America. He thinks it will be perfectly straightforward to ship children off to his daughter there. We discussed the idealised conception of the USA as a place for refugees and the true situation in the war, when Jewish refugees had difficulty obtaining visas and when a boatload was turned away from New York harbour and sent back to their deaths. If there was something that seems dated about the book, it would be the cultural clichés— the French are dirty and give their children lots of wine and coffee, the British hero is decent and persevering and takes on a task that Nicole (as a French woman) pretends not to comprehend, and America is a land of milk and honey (or rather swimming pools and large houses).
Julie was intrigued by the frame of the novel that showed Howard in his Gentlemen’s club. She found it both appealing and difficult to imagine. We confirmed that the institution was an important part of upper class British culture. Men went from being looked after at boarding school then at university and finally at their club. The most prestigious ones are still there.
On the frame for the narrative in which Howard and David Rintoul sit in their club sipping Madera while the bombs fall on London, Wendy found that it strained the reader’s credulity. The narrative is way too detailed to be recounted in a few hours. Why did Shute choose it then? One answer was that it would be too immodest to have Howard tell the story himself. It would be too much like boasting. Katharine commented that “despite the fact that M. Howard was relating the tale of the perilous journey, after-the-fact, in his Gentleman's Club, I had a feeling of dread in reading the first third of the book. We readers know that the German Blitzkrieg would immediately cut off all avenues of escape.” This gives another insight into the choice of the frame. It gives readers a sense of security during the ensuing adventures. We know that Howard, at least, got out of France safely.
We liked the irony at the end when the porter says that Howard’s holiday in France doesn’t seem to have restored him. He looks ten years older after his ordeal. The journey itself ends with irony as the woman welcoming the refugees describes Howard as a horrible old man who didn’t take care of the children, since they are in a filthy state after their adventures.
Rosie asked what we felt was the worst moment in the book. We thought that the worst moment was the bombing of the escaping families when Pierre’s parents are killed. Also the episode when the German officer questions Howard as a spy is pretty tense. We decided that this may have been the officer’s attempt at diverting attention from his real motive, which was to persuade Howard to take his half Jewish niece out of France with the other children. Although Howard was not tortured, he had to watch the British spy being shot.
There was a lengthy discussion of people’s experience of war—memories related by our group’s parents. Rationing and shortages were a big part of ordinary family life. We were surprised that oranges and chocolate were so prominent in the children’s diet on the road. Rosie assured us that at that moment, just as the Germans were entering France, people still had some of everything. Of course it’s not the case later. Rosie told an amusing story that her parents passed down. As a toddler she happened upon an American soldier and his girlfriend making out in the bushes. To get rid of her, the soldier gave her a bar of chocolate that her parents then eked out over several weeks as a rare and precious treat.
We discussed Katharine’s comment that the book may have ended differently if written nowadays, with a coda about how the children fared in America. We wondered too whether Nicole would have joined the resistance. But focusing on the following episodes would have detracted from Howard’s story. And anyway, the novel was published shortly after the events it relates, so the ending as it is is appropriate.
Julie put in a word for the novel’s style. She found it refreshing to read a narrative that unfolds in chronological order. She thought the simple language and clear style was appropriate for an engineer. The prose is not poetic but rather journalistic, almost Hemingwayesque. There are descriptions of sensual effects like the smell coffee. Rosie liked the way the author weaves together smaller story lines throughout the book. She particularly enjoyed how Nevil Shute developed John Howard into a selfless man, a true hero. She could imagine Mr. Howard's heart growing as the story unfolds.
For those who want to read more books by Nevil Shute, Rosie recommends A Town Like Alice (World best sellers no.17) and Trustee from the Toolroom, (Shute’s last book, 1960). Another recommendation of a novel about wartime England is Goodnight Mr Tom by Michelle Magorian.
